Working With a Farm Tax Specialist
How to find, interview and work with a CPA, enrolled agent or tax attorney who understands agriculture, and how to prepare so the relationship saves money.
A farm tax specialist is a tax professional who regularly works with agricultural clients and understands the issues that set farms apart: cash and accrual methods, Schedule F, deferred payment contracts, crop insurance elections, livestock sales, depreciation, income averaging, entity returns and agricultural payroll. A general preparer can do a competent job on a simple farm. A specialist tends to add value in planning, in unusual transactions and in representation when something goes wrong.
The relationship works best when you treat the specialist as a year-round adviser rather than a once-a-year form filler. Share information early, ask before big purchases and sales, and keep your records in a form your adviser can use. The IRS Farmer's Tax Guide gives you a baseline so you can follow the conversation. This article explains how to choose and work with a specialist.
Types of tax professionals
| Professional | What they do | Good fit for |
|---|---|---|
| Certified public accountant | Prepares returns, plans, handles entity and financial statement work, can represent clients | Most operating farms, entities, lenders needing statements |
| Enrolled agent | Federal tax specialist authorized to represent taxpayers | Return preparation, notices, examinations |
| Tax attorney | Gives legal tax advice, handles disputes and structuring | Disputes, estate and entity design, serious notices |
| Bookkeeper | Records transactions and runs payroll reports | Monthly records |
| Volunteer tax program | Free preparation for eligible taxpayers | Simple, lower-income returns |
Credential rules vary, so ask any prospective adviser about licensing and check with your state board when appropriate. For a comparison of do-it-yourself and hired help, see farm tax software vs professional help.
Where to look
- Ask neighbors, your lender, the Farm Credit association or your Extension office for names. Use the Farm Credit locator and Cooperative Extension to find local contacts.
- Ask your attorney or insurance agent whom they recommend.
- Look for advisers who attend farm tax schools or ag conferences.
- Ask about the share of clients who are farmers or ranchers.
Questions to ask before you hire
- How many farm clients do you serve, and of what types?
- Do you handle entity returns, payroll and planning?
- Will you meet with us before year end for planning?
- How do you charge: hourly, fixed fee or by form?
- Who actually prepares and reviews my return?
- How do you handle notices and examinations, and is that included?
- What do you need from me, and by when?
- How do you communicate, and how fast do you respond?
What fees look like
Fees vary widely by region, complexity and the services included. Ask for a written engagement letter that describes services, fee structure, what is excluded, and what happens if you receive a notice. Avoid anyone who bases a fee on a percentage of your refund or who promises a particular result. A planning meeting in the fall is often a wise investment. See how to tax plan for a profitable farm year.
What to bring and when
Prepare a clean package: prior returns, a profit and loss summary, a depreciation schedule, loan statements, payroll records, settlement sheets, government payment forms and entity documents. Use how to organize farm receipts for taxes to keep records tidy. Send documents securely, not as ordinary email attachments if the service offers a secure portal. Share changes during the year, such as a new employee, a land purchase or a family transfer.
A worked example
A hypothetical 400-acre grain farm meets with a farm CPA in October. The owner brings a year-to-date report, a list of equipment needs and a summary of unsold grain. The CPA projects net farm profit of 140,000 dollars and discusses options with a rough look at the trade-offs. The meeting costs one hour of professional time.
Suppose the CPA's fee for the planning meeting is one hour and the owner decides to defer 25,000 dollars of grain sales into the next year after finding that next year is projected lower. The owner's projected profit changes from 140,000 to 115,000 dollars this year, since 140,000 minus 25,000 equals 115,000, and next year's rises by the same 25,000 dollars. If next year's expected profit were 90,000 dollars, the new figure is 115,000 (90,000 plus 25,000), which matches this year's 115,000, so the deferral smooths income. The value is in the information as much as the deduction. Had the owner waited until March, the sales timing would already be fixed. This is a simplified illustration, and the actual tax effect depends on all of the owner's facts.
Keeping the relationship healthy
- Set a calendar of meetings: fall planning, January data delivery, spring review.
- Share decisions before you make them.
- Ask the specialist to explain choices in plain language.
- Keep a list of questions and bring it to each meeting.
- Give your adviser permission to talk to your lender and attorney when helpful.
- Review the engagement letter each year.
For large decisions that involve other advisers, coordinate. A succession plan, for example, involves an attorney, a CPA and sometimes a lender. See how to select a farm estate attorney and how to find a farm attorney.
Red flags
- Promises of guaranteed refunds or large savings.
- Unwillingness to sign the return as preparer.
- Pushing complex shelters or schemes.
- Lack of a written engagement.
- Poor communication or missed deadlines.
- Requests to alter records or leave out income.
If you suspect a preparer of misconduct, you may report concerns to the appropriate state board or the IRS. Do not sign a return you have not reviewed. Keep in mind that the signer is responsible for accuracy. See farm tax mistakes that cost money.
Farm families tend to be loyal to their mechanics, vets and accountants for decades, and for good reason. FARM.FM Rural is full of stories about trusted local professionals, and the jokes at FARM.FM cover the other kind.
When to call a professional
If you do not yet have a tax adviser, start with a CPA or enrolled agent who works with farms, and add an attorney for entity, estate or dispute issues. Bring prior returns, entity documents, current-year records and a list of goals and concerns. Your FSA office, lender and Extension educator can recommend names. Ask for a first meeting to decide if the fit is right before sharing sensitive records.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need a specialist if my farm is small?
Not always, but a small farm with employees, an entity or unusual events may benefit. A single consultation can help decide.
What is the difference between a CPA and an enrolled agent?
Both can prepare returns and represent taxpayers before the IRS, but they have different credentials and training paths. A CPA is licensed by a state board, while an enrolled agent is authorized by the IRS.
Can my tax specialist also do bookkeeping?
Some can, though bookkeeping may be provided by staff or a separate provider. Ask what is included and who is responsible for accuracy.
How often should I meet with my adviser?
At least once before year end and once after the return is filed. More meetings help in years with major changes such as a purchase, sale, hire or family transfer.