How Crop Insurance Proceeds Are Taxed
Learn how crop insurance indemnity payments are reported, when you may elect to defer them to the next year, and how federal disaster payments are treated.
Crop insurance proceeds are generally taxable income in the year you receive them, because they replace income from crops you would have sold. Farmers report them on Schedule F, usually on the line for crop insurance proceeds and federal crop disaster payments. In some cases, cash-method farmers may elect to include the proceeds in the following year instead.
The deferral election is real, narrow and easy to get wrong. It applies only when you would normally sell the damaged crop in a later year, and it must cover all crops from the same disaster. This guide explains the reporting, the election and the traps. It is general information, not tax advice; confirm details in IRS Publication 225 and with a preparer. For program details see USDA RMA.
Reporting basics
Crop insurance indemnities arrive with a statement from the insurance provider. If the payment is for lost yield or revenue that would have been income, it is taxed like crop sales. Premiums you paid are generally deductible as a farm expense, see deducting farm insurance premiums. The statement may show the crops and units covered, which helps you decide whether the deferral election is available. Proceeds from insurance on equipment or buildings follow different rules, such as casualty loss rules.
The deferral election
A cash-method farmer who normally sells the crop in the year after it is harvested may elect to report the insurance proceeds in the following year. The election typically must be made with the return for the year of damage, by the due date including extensions, and it covers all crops that are part of the same trade or business damaged in the same year. You attach a statement with details to the return. If you do not make it with the original return, you may lose the option, though late relief is sometimes possible by following IRS procedures.
| Question | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Is the crop normally sold in the following year? | Basic eligibility test |
| Was the loss caused by drought, flood or another natural disaster? | Usually required |
| Do you use the cash method? | Required |
| Did you receive proceeds in the damage year? | Required for the election to matter |
| Did you elect for all affected crops? | All or nothing for the business |
Federal disaster payments
Payments from federal disaster programs administered by USDA, such as those described by the FSA disaster assistance pages, are often treated like crop insurance proceeds for deferral purposes if they are paid as a result of crop damage. Payments for lost livestock feed, for example, have their own rules. Read the program notice and the Form 1099-G that comes with it, and ask your preparer.
A worked example
A hypothetical 450-acre farm usually sells all of its corn in the spring after harvest. A drought cuts yields, and the farm receives 90,000 dollars of crop insurance proceeds in November, plus 30,000 dollars of other grain sales in the same year. Without an election, the farm reports 90,000 plus 30,000, or 120,000 dollars of income this year. If the farm makes the deferral election and meets the tests, it reports 30,000 dollars this year, and 90,000 dollars next year with its spring grain sales. The election shifts income but does not reduce the total.
When deferral helps
Deferral can help in a bad year to avoid pushing a low-income year even lower while a good year follows, or the opposite when income this year is very high. It can backfire if next year is also high. Use your projections and consider income averaging, farm tax brackets and farm income deferral strategies. Also consider how deferral affects loan covenants and self-employment tax, which is based on the year income is reported.
Records to keep
- Insurance policy and claim documents
- Settlement statements with dates and amounts
- Production and sales history showing normal sales timing
- A copy of the election statement filed with the return
- Correspondence from USDA or your agent
For documentation of the loss itself, see how to document crop damage. Insurance people and tax people sometimes talk past each other, much like two neighbors disagreeing about where the property line was in 1974; FARM.FM Satire might find something funny in that, but your preparer will want paperwork.
Revenue protection, prevented planting and other payment types
Not every crop insurance payment looks alike. Yield and revenue policies pay when production or revenue falls below a guarantee. Prevented planting payments compensate when weather keeps you from planting, and their tax treatment depends on facts, so ask your preparer. Replant payments often offset the cost of replanting and may be treated differently from indemnities for lost production. Payments under whole-farm policies cover revenue across enterprises. Read your claim statement and policy for the type of payment, and keep the loss adjuster's worksheet. The USDA Risk Management Agency explains policy types, and our guides on crop insurance basics and whole farm revenue protection give program background. The tax result may also differ for landlords who share crop risk. A farm family learning policy terms often finds that the best humor comes late in the season, as the stories at FARM.FM Farming confirm.
Landlords and tenants should settle who receives and reports each payment. Under a crop-share lease, the landlord typically shares in the indemnity according to the lease, and each party reports their share. Ask your agent for a statement showing how a payment was divided, and make sure each party's 1099 matches what they actually received. If the insured unit includes ground rented from several owners, the allocation can get complicated, and a short written note from each owner can prevent trouble later.
When to call a professional
A CPA or enrolled agent should decide whether to elect deferral and prepare the statement. Your crop insurance agent can supply claim documents and clarify coverage. Your FSA county office can explain disaster program payments. Bring policy documents, 1099s, sales history for at least three years and your prior returns.
Frequently asked questions
Are crop insurance premiums deductible?
Generally yes, as a farm business expense, though subsidized portions and special situations may need review.
Does the deferral apply to prevented planting payments?
Rules can differ, so ask your preparer. The type of payment and normal sales pattern matter.
Can an accrual farmer defer?
The one-year deferral election is generally for cash-method farmers. Accrual farmers follow their own accounting rules.
What if I forgot to make the election?
Ask a preparer right away about amending or requesting relief. Time limits apply.