Farm Worker Immigration Compliance
How farm employers can follow work authorization rules, complete Form I-9 correctly, avoid discrimination, understand E-Verify and H-2A options, and respond to a government audit or notice.
Farm employers have a legal duty to verify that every person they hire is authorized to work in the United States, and an equal duty not to discriminate while doing so. The core tool is Form I-9, which every employer completes for each new employee, citizen or not. Mistakes are common, even among careful farms, and paperwork errors can lead to penalties during a government inspection. The goal of a compliance program is to follow the process the same way for every hire, keep clean records and know where to get help.
This topic is sensitive and the stakes for workers and employers are high. The material below is informational and focused on compliance, not on avoiding the law. Immigration law is complex and changes, so work with an immigration attorney and use official government sources. Never threaten a worker's immigration status in response to a wage, safety or other complaint.
The Form I-9 basics
Form I-9 has sections for the employee and the employer. In general, the employee completes Section 1 no later than the first day of work, and the employer completes Section 2 within three business days of the start date after reviewing the employee's original documents. The employee chooses which acceptable documents to present from the official list, and the employer may not demand specific ones. Retain completed forms for the period the form instructions require, and keep them separate from general personnel files so they can be produced when requested.
| Step | Who | Common error |
|---|---|---|
| Section 1 | Employee | Incomplete fields or missing signature |
| Document review | Employer | Asking for specific documents or too many documents |
| Section 2 | Employer | Late completion or missing document details |
| Reverification | Employer | Missing an expiration date |
| Storage | Employer | Mixing with payroll files or discarding too soon |
If you hire through a labor contractor, ask who completes the forms and what you may inspect. See farm labor contractor rules. For the full hiring sequence, read hiring farm employees legally.
Avoiding discrimination
Federal law prohibits employers from treating people differently in hiring or verification because of national origin or citizenship status. Examples of risky behavior include asking only workers who look or sound foreign for documents, refusing to accept valid documents, or demanding more than the form requires. Apply the same process to every new hire, and train anyone who handles the paperwork. See discrimination laws and farm hiring and background checks for farm employees. Information about worker rights is also available on the EEOC site.
E-Verify and program options
E-Verify is an online system that compares Form I-9 data with government records. It is voluntary for many employers but required by some states, certain federal contractors or particular situations. If you use it, follow program rules exactly and use it for all new hires, not selected ones. Check your state's law on whether it is required.
The H-2A program allows eligible employers to bring in temporary agricultural workers when they cannot find enough U.S. workers, and it has its own pay, housing, transportation and recruitment requirements. Read H-2A visa program explained for farmers and the DOL H-2A resources before deciding. Program workers still require attention to Form I-9, and programs have strict rules on fees charged to workers.
What to do if you receive a notice of inspection
An employer may receive a notice that the government will inspect Form I-9 records, usually with a few days to produce them. If this happens:
- Do not ignore it. Note the deadline and contact an immigration attorney right away.
- Gather the forms and supporting records, and do not alter, backdate or discard anything.
- Do not retaliate against any worker or tell workers to leave.
- Review results with counsel and correct technical errors only as advised.
- Plan for staffing, since an audit can affect workers who are found not to be authorized.
Penalties may apply for paperwork errors and for knowingly employing unauthorized workers, and the amounts change, so do not rely on memory.
Humane and lawful handling of workers
Employers should treat workers with respect during any compliance matter. Do not threaten to call immigration authorities as a response to a complaint, and do not hold identity documents or wages. Workers who are victims of labor exploitation or trafficking may have protections, and a worker in danger can call emergency services. If a worker needs legal help, direct them to legal aid, which can be found through the Legal Services Corporation. Related rules on migrant and seasonal workers are in migrant worker legal protections.
Worked example: a hypothetical 200-acre nursery
A hypothetical 200-acre nursery hires 15 employees each spring. The owner designates one office employee to handle Form I-9, trains her on the form instructions and creates a calendar for Section 2 deadlines and for reverification dates. On a worker's first day, the employee completes Section 1 and chooses documents from the list. Within three business days, the office employee reviews original documents, completes Section 2 and files the form in a separate binder.
When a worker's work authorization document is about to expire, a calendar reminder prompts the office to ask for updated documents, without asking for a specific type. Once a year, the owner has a lawyer review a sample of forms and correct errors. The owner also asks the labor contractor that supplies extra pickers for its own compliance paperwork. When the nursery receives a notice of inspection, the files are organized, and the attorney guides the response. The owner counted staff by the book and did not guess.
Compliance is serious, but a little humor helps: the satire at FARM.FM is good company when paperwork stacks up, and FARM.FM USA covers national ag news.
When to call a professional
An immigration attorney is the right expert for Form I-9 audits, E-Verify questions, H-2A applications and any notice from a government agency. An employment attorney can handle discrimination and retaliation questions. A payroll provider can help with tracking dates. Workers who need help can contact legal aid or a recognized accredited representative. Bring your Form I-9 files, a list of employees and hire dates, any contractor agreements and any government notices. See also recordkeeping requirements for farm employers.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need a Form I-9 for every farm employee?
Generally yes, for every person hired as an employee, including family members who are employees and seasonal workers. Independent contractors are treated differently, but misclassifying an employee as a contractor creates risk.
Can I ask for a specific document, such as a green card?
No. The employee chooses which acceptable documents to present from the list. Demanding specific documents can be discrimination.
Is E-Verify required on my farm?
It depends on your state and on certain contracts. Check state law and consult counsel.
What if I think a worker's documents are not valid?
Do not accuse the worker or fire him on a hunch. Follow the form's process, document what you saw and ask an immigration attorney how to proceed.