Farm Business Structure Changes and Taxes
How converting or restructuring a farm, such as moving from sole proprietor to LLC, adding partners or electing S corporation status, can affect basis, depreciation recapture, debt, payroll and state taxes.
Changing a farm's legal structure can be tax-neutral, tax-costly or tax-beneficial, depending on the type of change and how it is done. A simple move from sole proprietor to a single-member LLC that is ignored for income tax often changes little at the federal income tax level. Adding partners, converting to a corporation, electing S corporation status or moving land and equipment between entities can trigger issues involving basis, depreciation recapture, debt, payroll and state tax. The safe approach is to plan the tax result before you file anything.
Tax law here is technical and changes, and state rules vary. This article is general information, not tax or legal advice, so work with a CPA or enrolled agent and an attorney.
Common types of structure changes
| Change | Typical federal income tax effect | Watch for |
|---|---|---|
| Sole proprietor to single-member LLC (disregarded) | Usually reported the same on Schedule F | New EIN needs, state fees, insurance and titles |
| Sole proprietor to multi-member LLC or partnership | New partnership return, partners share income | Contributions, basis, debt allocation, self-employment tax |
| Partnership to LLC taxed as partnership | Often limited tax effect if structured correctly | State rules, titles, lender consent |
| LLC or partnership to S corporation | New corporate tax status | Eligibility, reasonable wages, built-in gains and basis |
| LLC or partnership to C corporation | Separate corporate taxpayer | Potential double taxation, exit costs |
| Moving assets between related entities | May be nontaxable contribution or taxable sale | Recapture, related-party rules, state transfer taxes |
| Dissolving or merging entities | Distribution or liquidation rules | Final returns, gain recognition |
See converting a partnership to an LLC, S corporation election for farm businesses and farm business structure and tax implications for specific changes.
Basis and gain
Tax basis is generally what you paid for an asset, adjusted for improvements and depreciation. When you contribute property to an entity, the entity's basis in the property and your basis in your ownership interest are usually tied to your old basis rather than to current market value. When you sell or transfer for value, the difference between amount received and basis can create taxable gain. The IRS Publication 551 explains the concept.
Land held until death can receive a step-up in basis for heirs, but lifetime transfers may carry over the donor's basis. This can be a key reason to hold off on moving appreciated land until you know the full plan. See step-up in basis rules for farm land.
Depreciation recapture
Farm equipment and buildings that have been depreciated can create ordinary income, called depreciation recapture, when sold above their depreciated basis. That is reported on Form 4797. Some restructurings are not taxable sales, but others may be treated as sales, especially when debt is relieved or property is transferred for something other than an ownership interest. Section 179 and bonus depreciation are dollar and percentage rules set by law and changed over time, so check current IRS figures before relying on them. Details are in IRS Publication 946 and depreciation rules for farm equipment.
A hypothetical example
A hypothetical farm owner plans to contribute a tractor to a new LLC. The tractor was bought for 150,000 dollars, and depreciation deducted so far totals 110,000 dollars, so the adjusted basis is 40,000 dollars. It is worth 95,000 dollars today. If the owner sold it to the new entity for 95,000 dollars, the gain would be 95,000 minus 40,000, which equals 55,000 dollars, and because the gain is no more than the depreciation taken, it would generally be treated as recapture rather than capital gain. If instead the contribution qualifies as a nontaxable exchange for an ownership interest, the gain may not be recognized now, but it stays embedded in the asset. The owner and CPA should compare both options, and also check lender and state rules. Tax planning does not require a sense of humor, though the satire at FARM.FM helps.
Debt matters
Debt can change the tax result. When an entity assumes debt on contributed property, tax rules look at whether liabilities exceed basis, and partnerships allocate debt among partners for basis purposes. If debt shifts, a partner may have taxable gain or lose basis needed to deduct losses. Lenders must approve many transfers of secured property. See how to transfer farm assets between entities for a transfer checklist.
Payroll, self-employment and employment tax
Structure affects who is an employee and how earnings are taxed:
- Self-employment tax: generally 15.3 percent combined, applied to 92.35 percent of net earnings from self-employment. General partners and active LLC members are often subject to it. See the IRS self-employment tax page.
- S corporation owners: owners who work must be paid reasonable wages subject to payroll tax. Distributions beyond wages are not subject to the same payroll tax, but the reasonable-wage requirement is closely watched.
- New employer accounts: a new entity that hires workers needs its own payroll registrations. Agricultural employer rules are in the Employer's Tax Guide and Circular A, and farm payroll forms such as Form 943 may apply.
- State unemployment and workers compensation: coverage must follow the right employer.
See farm payroll tax obligations explained and farm payroll setup and compliance.
State and local taxes
States differ on:
- Transfer or documentary taxes on deeds
- Property tax reassessment when land moves
- Sales and use tax on equipment transfers
- LLC fees and entity-level taxes
- Agricultural use valuation continuing or being lost
- Treatment of S corporations and partnerships
Check with your county assessor, state revenue department and attorney before recording a deed. Related issues are covered in farm entity compliance requirements yearly.
A planning sequence
- Write down why you want to change the structure and what you hope to achieve.
- Gather current financial statements, tax returns, depreciation schedules and loan documents.
- Ask your CPA to model the tax result of each option, including state tax.
- Ask your attorney about title, consent and agreement issues.
- Talk to your lender and insurance agent.
- Choose the timing, often at a quiet point in the year but with attention to year-end effects.
- Sign documents, transfer assets and update filings.
- Update bookkeeping, payroll, and program records.
- File the right returns, including final or short-year returns where required.
If this seems like a lot of paperwork, it is. For a smile in the middle of it, FARM.FM Tomorrow reminds you that the weather, at least, never needs a filing.
When to call a professional
A CPA or enrolled agent should review any structural change before it happens, because tax effects often cannot be undone afterward. An attorney should draft the documents and handle state filings. Your lender must consent to transfers of collateral, and your insurance agent should update policies. Bring the last three years of returns, current depreciation schedules, a list of assets with values, entity documents and a summary of what you want to accomplish. For farm-specific tax background, the Farmer's Tax Guide and farmdoc daily are useful.
Frequently asked questions
Will forming an LLC change my taxes?
A single-member LLC is generally ignored for federal income tax, so you usually still report on Schedule F. A multi-member LLC is generally taxed as a partnership unless it elects another classification. State taxes and fees may differ.
Do I owe tax when I move equipment into an LLC?
Not always. A qualifying contribution may not be taxed immediately, but sales, debt relief and recapture can create tax. Ask a CPA before moving anything.
Is it better to change structure at the start of the year?
Often it is easier for records and payroll, but the best timing depends on your facts. Your CPA can compare options.
Can I undo a structure change if the tax result is bad?
Sometimes it is hard or impossible, and undoing it may create a second tax event. That is why planning before the change is so important.